Citation Atlas
29 CFR Part 1926
1926.652
Requirements for protective systems

1926.652 Trench Cave-In Protection: citations, penalties and recently cited employers

Data as of November 16, 2026 · citations issued Nov 16, 2025 to Nov 16, 2026

Workers in excavations must be protected from cave-ins by an adequate protective system such as sloping, benching, shoring, or trench boxes, unless the excavation is in stable rock or less than 5 feet deep with no indication of potential cave-in. Systems for excavations deeper than 20 feet must be designed by a registered professional engineer. The section details design options and installation and removal procedures.

534inspections cited
624alleged violation items
$4,965median proposed penalty per citation (grouped items combined)
$4,709median current penalty per citation (grouped items combined)
20%of items contested

OSHA often groups related violations into one citation (items such as 01002A and 01002B) and records the group's penalty on one item, sometimes under another standard. The medians count each citation with an item under 1926.652 once, at the group's combined penalty. 14% of items carried no separate penalty: 53% of those were grouped with a related violation in the same citation, which carries the penalty, and the rest were cited with no proposed fine.

What the standard requires

Hazards it addresses

Cited heavily among utility, plumbing, and underground pipeline contractors.

Plain-language summary written for this site; it is not the regulatory text and not legal advice. Read the official text at eCFR.

Citations by month

Inspections with citations issued, by month of issuance. Hatched months are incomplete: citations reach the public data about a month after issuance.

Most-cited paragraphs

ParagraphWhat it coversItemsInspectionsMedian proposed penalty per citation
1926.652(a)(1)Each employee in an excavation must be protected from cave-ins by an adequate protective system.487470$4,965
1926.652(g)(1)(ii)Shield systems such as trench boxes must not be subjected to loads exceeding their design and must be installed properly.1515$7,570
1926.652(g)(2)Shield systems such as trench boxes must not be subjected to loads exceeding their design and must be installed properly.1313$4,965
1926.652(g)(1)(iii)Shield systems such as trench boxes must not be subjected to loads exceeding their design and must be installed properly.1010$10,049
1926.652(b)Design of sloping and benching systems must follow one of the permitted options.99$6,620
1926.652(c)(2)(i)Design of support systems, shield systems, and other protective systems.99$7,944
1926.652(c)(2)(iii)Design of support systems, shield systems, and other protective systems.99$0
1926.652(b)(2)Design of sloping and benching systems must follow one of the permitted options.88$4,734
1926.652(c)(3)(iii)Design of support systems, shield systems, and other protective systems.66$4,468
1926.652(d)(1)66$10,521
1926.652(d)(2)66$4,090
1926.652(b)(1)(i)Design of sloping and benching systems must follow one of the permitted options.55$6,620
1926.652(a)(1)(ii)Each employee in an excavation must be protected from cave-ins by an adequate protective system.44$6,990
1926.652(c)Design of support systems, shield systems, and other protective systems.44$0
1926.652(c)(4)(i)Design of support systems, shield systems, and other protective systems.44$10,392

Penalties

Across 624 alleged items, OSHA and state-plan offices proposed $8,879,960 in initial penalties. The current total in the public data is $7,552,032, 15% lower after settlements, contests and amendments.

By violation type: Serious 75%; Other-than-serious 12%; Repeat 8%; Willful 5%.

Trends and abatement

From December 2025 to August 2026 (months with complete data), 422 inspections citing 1926.652 had citations first issued, 3% fewer than in the same months a year earlier (433).

Abatement time: for the 378 alleged items under 1926.652 with an abatement date, OSHA set a median of 20 days from issuance to correct the hazard (a quarter got more than 28 days).

Penalty distribution

Half of the initial (proposed) penalties per citation (grouped items combined) were $4,965 or less; a quarter were above $11,585, and one in ten above $28,515.

Initial (proposed) penalty per citation (grouped items combined)CountShare
Under $1,000468%
$1,000 to $4,99926845%
$5,000 to $14,99917128%
$15,000 to $49,9997212%
$50,000 or more437%

Industries cited most under 1926.652

Industry (NAICS)Cited inspectionsShare
Utility System Construction 237120438%
Other Specialty Trade Contractors 238910219%
Building Equipment Contractors 23825811%
Foundation, Structure, and Building Exterior Contractors 2381387%
Nonresidential Building Construction 2362367%
Highway, Street, and Bridge Construction 2373326%
Residential Building Construction 2361153%
Other Heavy and Civil Engineering Construction 2379112%

Citations by state

StateInspections citedItemsInitial penaltiesCurrent penalties
Texas4550$613,420$508,467
Illinois3339$420,099$278,726
Ohio2930$423,666$139,189
New York2733$615,091$612,852
Florida2629$203,117$160,055
Minnesota2627$63,950$51,780
Massachusetts2552$2,545,272$2,466,296
North Carolina2123$133,750$125,435
Pennsylvania2121$276,261$218,152
Colorado1921$180,305$148,467
Tennessee1927$202,850$192,850
Virginia1920$359,426$349,018
Kentucky1717$75,600$63,840
Missouri1617$101,289$73,587
New Jersey1515$192,645$161,783
South Dakota1416$206,536$137,494
Wisconsin1313$112,670$67,118
North Dakota1115$171,024$140,772
Arizona1016$191,994$191,994
Connecticut1013$628,622$546,350
Top 20 of 47 states and territories.

By industry

Recently cited establishments

Alleged violations. Citations are allegations with proposed penalties until they become final orders; each record shows its status label, initial and current penalty as of November 16, 2026. About this data · Methodology

Official records: each osha.gov link opens the official record, next to its inspection number. If osha.gov asks you to verify you're human and then shows its homepage, search that number at OSHA's Establishment Search.

EstablishmentLocationIssuedAlleged itemsInitial penaltyCurrent penaltyStatus and deadlinesSource
Brian Capone Land Services, LLC Greenwich, CT Oct 13, 2026 1 $3,972 $1,986 OpenAbatement due Dec 11, 2026Contest deadline ~Nov 3, 2026 (est.) osha.gov #349191601
Twin Ports Excavating of Duluth Duluth, MN Oct 12, 2026 1 $1,650 $1,650 Final orderAbatement due Oct 16, 2026 osha.gov #349206177
Jonesborough - Water Department Limestone, TN Oct 12, 2026 1 $0 $0 Final orderAbatement due Nov 12, 2026 osha.gov #349195495
Hatch Landscape and Design Brockton, MA Oct 9, 2026 1 $11,916 $5,000 Informal settlement osha.gov #349095786
Commonwealth Construction & Utilities, Inc. Medford, MA Oct 8, 2026 1 $3,972 $3,000 Informal settlementAbatement due Dec 18, 2026 osha.gov #349129247
City of Houston - Mayor's Office Houston, AK Oct 8, 2026 2 $72,826 $49,654 OpenContest deadline ~Oct 30, 2026 (est.) osha.gov #348876772
Fox Tapping Inc. Columbia, PA Oct 7, 2026 1 $4,965 $4,965 Final order osha.gov #349058305
Johnson Plumbing Co. Memphis, TN Oct 7, 2026 1 $4,000 $4,000 Final orderAbatement due Oct 22, 2026 osha.gov #349084335
Thalle Construction Co., Inc. Fort Worth, TX Oct 6, 2026 1 $13,240 $7,756 Informal settlement osha.gov #348957929
Next Generation Excavating LLC Chattanooga, TN Oct 6, 2026 1 $4,000 $0 Informal settlementAbatement due Oct 19, 2026 osha.gov #349121251
Engitex LLC Conroe, TX Oct 6, 2026 1 $4,965 $4,965 ContestedAbatement due Oct 19, 2026Contested Nov 2, 2026 osha.gov #348871005
Ray Services Inc. Lawrence, MA Oct 6, 2026 1 $105,929 $50,000 Informal settlement osha.gov #348957663
Commpath Construction, LLC Pensacola, FL Oct 5, 2026 1 $0 $0 Informal settlementAbatement due Nov 3, 2026 osha.gov #349088526
Dirt Works Unlimited LLC Brandenburg, KY Oct 5, 2026 1 $4,900 $4,900 ContestedAbatement due Oct 23, 2026Contested Oct 16, 2026 osha.gov #348977703
Pophams Trucking LLC Brandenburg, KY Oct 5, 2026 1 $3,500 $3,500 ContestedAbatement due Oct 23, 2026Contested Oct 26, 2026 osha.gov #348983172
John Burns Construction Company, LLC Deerfield, IL Oct 2, 2026 1 $9,268 $9,268 Informal settlement osha.gov #349056234
Zeyco Construction LLC North Reading, MA Oct 1, 2026 1 $3,972 $2,780 Informal settlementAbatement due Dec 11, 2026 osha.gov #349121046
Jayde Underground LLC Wilmington, DE Oct 1, 2026 1 $3,405 $2,384 Informal settlementAbatement due Oct 21, 2026 osha.gov #348867854
Daniels of Philadelphia Plumbing Philadelphia, PA Sep 30, 2026 1 $2,412 $1,688 Informal settlement osha.gov #348910274
Aspen Earthworks, Inc. Sparks, NV Sep 30, 2026 1 $11,823 $11,823 Final order osha.gov #349013821
Berkowatts Electric LLC East Brunswick, NJ Sep 30, 2026 1 $14,895 $7,448 Informal settlementAbatement due Oct 27, 2026 osha.gov #349136697
M. O' Herron Company Webster Springs, WV Sep 30, 2026 1 $21,281 $21,281 ContestedAbatement due Nov 18, 2026Contested Oct 7, 2026 osha.gov #349139816
Icon LLC Dodge Center, MN Sep 29, 2026 1 $2,200 $1,320 Informal settlementAbatement due Oct 5, 2026 osha.gov #349173187
Park Construction Company White Bear Lake, MN Sep 29, 2026 1 $4,900 $4,900 ContestedAbatement due Oct 5, 2026Contested Oct 7, 2026 osha.gov #349077818
Jr Civil, LLC Minot, ND Sep 29, 2026 2 $21,517 $21,517 OpenContest deadline ~Oct 21, 2026 (est.) osha.gov #349066449
Dave Perkins Contracting Inc. White Bear Lake, MN Sep 29, 2026 1 $1,400 $1,400 Final orderAbatement due Oct 5, 2026 osha.gov #349077800
Trans Florida Development Corp. Miami, FL Sep 29, 2026 1 $16,550 $11,585 Informal settlementAbatement due Nov 20, 2026 osha.gov #348851031
VC Equipment, Corp. Caguas, PR Sep 25, 2026 1 $115,860 $46,344 Informal settlementAbatement due Oct 21, 2026 osha.gov #348914755
Uno Construction Co., Inc. Clarendon Hills, IL Sep 25, 2026 1 $39,723 $19,890 Informal settlement osha.gov #349071936
Minger Construction Companies Inc. Minneapolis, MN Sep 25, 2026 2 $8,800 $8,800 ContestedAbatement due Sep 29, 2026Contested Oct 1, 2026 osha.gov #349166355
Caetano's Concrete Inc. East Boston, MA Sep 24, 2026 1 $33,103 $33,103 ContestedAbatement due Oct 2, 2026Contested Oct 7, 2026 osha.gov #348872979
MC Associates LLC Louisville, KY Sep 23, 2026 1 $3,500 $2,800 Informal settlementAbatement due Sep 28, 2026 osha.gov #348910993
Prime Structure Inc. Monroe, NY Sep 22, 2026 1 $4,965 $4,965 ContestedAbatement due Sep 28, 2026Contested Oct 30, 2026 osha.gov #348910407
Advanced Plan and Build LLC Monroe, NY Sep 22, 2026 2 $165,514 $165,514 ContestedAbatement due Sep 28, 2026Contested Oct 30, 2026 osha.gov #348910332
Century Max Industries Corp. Monroe, NY Sep 22, 2026 1 $11,585 $11,585 ContestedAbatement due Sep 28, 2026Contested Oct 30, 2026 osha.gov #349035709
Parkstone Inc. / Obstacle Systems Inc. dba Drip Drop Waterproofing Inc. Monroe, NY Sep 22, 2026 1 $165,514 $165,514 Final orderAbatement due Sep 28, 2026 osha.gov #349006031
Geo. Gradel Co. Toledo, OH Sep 22, 2026 1 $4,502 $2,251 Informal settlementAbatement due Oct 5, 2026 osha.gov #348917105
Name withheld (individual) Chambersburg, PA Sep 22, 2026 1 $165,514 $140,000 Informal settlementAbatement due Dec 1, 2026 osha.gov #348852955
Aems Development, LLC Blountville, TN Sep 22, 2026 1 $5,400 $5,400 Final orderAbatement due Oct 5, 2026 osha.gov #349034553
Delvalle Contractor Inc. Monroe, NY Sep 22, 2026 1 $4,965 $4,965 Final orderAbatement due Sep 28, 2026 osha.gov #349019497
The 40 most recent inspections citing 1926.652. Penalties shown are for the items under this standard only.

Notable employers cited under 1926.652

Largest proposed penalties under 1926.652 in the last 12 months (items under this standard only), among establishments with a detailed history page. Alleged violations; see each page for status and current penalty.

Often cited together

Questions

What does OSHA standard 1926.652 require?

Workers in excavations must be protected from cave-ins by an adequate protective system such as sloping, benching, shoring, or trench boxes, unless the excavation is in stable rock or less than 5 feet deep with no indication of potential cave-in. Systems for excavations deeper than 20 feet must be designed by a registered professional engineer. The section details design options and installation and removal procedures.

How often was 1926.652 cited in the last 12 months?

In the public data as of November 16, 2026, 1926.652 (Trench Cave-In Protection) appeared in 534 inspections with citations issued between Nov 16, 2025 and Nov 16, 2026, covering 624 alleged violation items.

Which part of 1926.652 is cited most?

1926.652(a)(1) was the most-cited paragraph, with 487 items: Each employee in an excavation must be protected from cave-ins by an adequate protective system.

Which states cite 1926.652 most often?

The most citations under 1926.652 in this period were issued in Texas, Illinois, Ohio.

What is the typical penalty for a 1926.652 violation?

Counting each citation once, the median initial (proposed) penalty was $4,965 per citation; the median current penalty after settlements and amendments was $4,709. OSHA often groups related violations (items such as 01002A and 01002B) into one citation with one penalty, recorded on one item and sometimes under another standard, so these figures combine the grouped items. 14% of items carried no separate penalty: 53% of those were grouped with a related violation in the same citation, which carries the penalty, and the rest were cited with no proposed fine. Totals for the items under 1926.652: $8,879,960 proposed, $7,552,032 current. Penalties vary by violation type, employer size and history, and State Plans set their own amounts.

Are 1926.652 citations final?

Not necessarily. A citation is an allegation until it becomes a final order. 20% of these items were contested, and many others were changed in settlements. Each listing shows its current status and a link to the official record.